Warrants Issued for David Carroll and Amy Baker

[Daphne]

JOINT PRESS RELEASE

MAYSVILLE POLICE DEPARTMENT, MASON COUNTY ATTORNEY AND COMMONWEALTH ATTORNEY
On April 20, 2007, Detective Ken Fuller of the Maysville Police Department obtained warrants for David Carroll and Amy Baker for the offense of Tampering with Physical Evidence, in violation of KRS 524.100. The offense is a Class D felony, punishable by up to five (5) years imprisonment.

The criminal complaints allege that on or about August 7, 2006, the Defendants disposed of the remains of Marcus Fiesel by throwing them in to the Ohio River from the William Harsha Bridge, in Mason County, Kentucky, for the purpose of destroying or concealing evidence in official proceedings related to the homicide of the said Marcus Fiesel. No bond was set for Carroll and for Baker in the amount of $50,000.00

The investigation into the alleged offense was conducted by Detective Ken Fuller and other members of the Maysville Police Department, with the cooperation of detectives with the Hamilton and Clermont County Sheriffs offices. The criminal complaint was prepared and submitted by Mason County Attorney John F. Estill and Kathryn B. Hendrickson, Commonwealth Attorney for the 19th Judicial District.

Other than this press release, no other statements will be made by any of the offices or agencies involved.

[PoliticallyConfused]

Too bad she can't get more, now if we can just get her tushy in Kentucky. Didn't she just get immunity in clermont county? Can't she be charged in brown county?

[Chuck]

If she comes I will video her....

[Flame]

According to Channel 12 News in Cincy Amy turned herself in but will fight extradition. The Clermont Co. Attorney was on and very furious over these charges being filed apparently because she was given immunity. Go to WCPO.com for further.

[Foxy]

OMG! THEY were upset that she was being charged???? Whatever! I am outraged that they DIDN'T charge her!!

(Wow, I gotta get control.... this is the second thread where I said I was outraged.... sheesh! LOL)

TO JOHN ESTILL AND ANYONE ELSE INVOLVED IN THIS PROSECUTION MASON COUNTY:
You have my complete support in this. Keep doing the right thing. I stand and applaud you all in your efforts to see this through, and bring her before a Judge to face her consequences for aiding and abetting in such a horrible act.

[Jeremy]

If she comes I will video her....

If you know when a prisoner is being transported, someone's not doing their job :)

[TheMan]

I'd pretend I was upset to if I was the prosecutor...

[Flame]

I'd pretend I was upset to if I was the prosecutor...

I can read between those lines.

[Chuck]

If you know when a prisoner is being transported, someone's not doing their job :)

Court dates are public record. When she arrives is public record.

[jlmer]

Lets this be a warning to all of Cincinnati, Dont come to Maysville Ky. and commit a crimes unless u can do the time. We are tired of the drugs and everything else they bring in here.. Way to go M.P.D.

[Jeremy]

Court dates are public record. When she arrives is public record.

Court dates are, but if they tell you when they're leaving point A for point B, that's a security problem. I don't know, maybe they do that. I wouldn't.

[wmjsmallwood]

mcpd and john estill ,tks! at least you are trying to do the right thing ,more that i can say for the other people involved in this case ,is it right to turn one murder lose to tell on another?,,,,something fishy about this whole case from the beginning ,dont you think?

[Daphne]

3:45 p.m. Judge Shriver says Baker's attorney had not presented any new arguments against her extradition and in favor of reduced bond, so he says he doesn't plan to change any decisions he made Friday. He sets a new hearing for May 17 at 3 p.m. Baker will stay in jail until that time unless she's bailed out and, according to an attorney, any time Baker serves as she fights her extradition would not count as time served on her possible conviction in Mason County.

Source (http://www.wlwt.com/news/12917546/detail.html)

[wmjsmallwood]

the children of the world and their parents,may sleep a little safer tonight knowing she is locked up and cant get to them!

[Maxwells]

I just want JUSTICE!!!!!!!!!!

[DecupldSolutions]

Lets this be a warning to all of Cincinnati, Dont come to Maysville Ky. and commit a crimes unless u can do the time. We are tired of the drugs and everything else they bring in here.. Way to go M.P.D.

Haha... what did the MPD have to do with Carroll extradition, charges filed? It would seem to be the work of Estill/Hendrickson. And what does that have to do with drugs from Cincy? Out of towners don't bring drugs to distribute. Locals go get them. Or have them shipped.

She did a bad thing. She will suffer. She is cast off in society. Why do my tax dollars have to spent on it? She was processed through the Ohio system. Whether we like the results or not, it should be left to pass. I think my tax dollars should deal with the local issues. One might say this is a local issue, but to that, again; she was processed through the Clermont Co. judicial system. Why take on another problem. We have enough of those here.

Now if she is convicted, my tax dollars have to pay for her to watch cable and eat 3 sqaures in a Ky prison. For 3 to 5 years. Tax dollars that could go to the education of area young people, water bill problem, local starving and abused people, community devlopement, etc.

Not to mention the cost of processing this case in our court system and attention drawn to area. Poor avenue of vengence. Karma will handle this sufficiently. Let my tax dollars handle the problems of Mason Co.

But the wheels are turning. Time to watch the monkies.

[kybikertrash]

She should be charged and it's a shame that KY has to do it because some idiots in OH decided not to.

As for our tax dollars paying for her to have 3 hots and a cot (and cable TV), we will still footing the bill for her in the form of welfare, food stamps, section 8 housing, heat assistance, etc., because she will probably never get a job because no one will hire her. So, at least in prison, she will not be living off the taxpayers AND have the privilage of being free to do whatever she wants to do every day. So there's the justice, imo.

[TheMan]

Haha... what did the MPD have to do with Carroll extradition, charges filed? It would seem to be the work of Estill/Hendrickson. And what does that have to do with drugs from Cincy? Out of towners don't bring drugs to distribute. Locals go get them. Or have them shipped.


You are very narrow minded, or maybe just sheltered.. Misinformed maybe? But definitely wrong..

[PoliticallyConfused]

Didn't the Detectives detect and wasn't it their findings that lead to the charges by Estill/Hendrickson. Maybe I was misinformed in law class.

[Flame]

Haha... what did the MPD have to do with Carroll extradition, charges filed? It would seem to be the work of Estill/Hendrickson. And what does that have to do with drugs from Cincy? Out of towners don't bring drugs to distribute. Locals go get them. Or have them shipped.

She did a bad thing. She will suffer. She is cast off in society. Why do my tax dollars have to spent on it? She was processed through the Ohio system. Whether we like the results or not, it should be left to pass. I think my tax dollars should deal with the local issues. One might say this is a local issue, but to that, again; she was processed through the Clermont Co. judicial system. Why take on another problem. We have enough of those here.

Now if she is convicted, my tax dollars have to pay for her to watch cable and eat 3 sqaures in a Ky prison. For 3 to 5 years. Tax dollars that could go to the education of area young people, water bill problem, local starving and abused people, community devlopement, etc.

Not to mention the cost of processing this case in our court system and attention drawn to area. Poor avenue of vengence. Karma will handle this sufficiently. Let my tax dollars handle the problems of Mason Co.

But the wheels are turning. Time to watch the monkies.

I agree your money can be better spent. Try using it for a therapy or an education. I'd rather my tax dollars go to execute her but that's not happening so I'll take the 3-5. I personally get tired of my tax dollars going to keep lazy people that are as able to work as I am but yet I work to keep them. Does not bother me one bit to use my money to house bad people and she is very very very bad people.

[tkcomer]

Did anybody see the article in the Cincinnati Enquirer? They're claiming Mason County had originally said they would honor the immunity deal, and have now backed out. That without Backer's testimony, Mason County would not have found out about the body dump off the bridge. And now, Mason County wants to take that testimony and use it to charge her here, which may violate her 5th amendment rights. Her attorney said it is unprecedented for other prosecutors to refuse to honor an immunity deal. I've always thought that is why Brown County didn't indict her. They could have leveled more serious charges against her. This could get ugly. Ohio hasn't said if they will turn her over yet. If she wins on the constitutional issue, she may turn around and sue Mason County for damages.

[Flame]

Did anybody see the article in the Cincinnati Enquirer? They're claiming Mason County had originally said they would honor the immunity deal, and have now backed out. That without Backer's testimony, Mason County would not have found out about the body dump off the bridge. And now, Mason County wants to take that testimony and use it to charge her here, which may violate her 5th amendment rights. Her attorney said it is unprecedented for other prosecutors to refuse to honor an immunity deal. I've always thought that is why Brown County didn't indict her. They could have leveled more serious charges against her. This could get ugly. Ohio hasn't said if they will turn her over yet. If she wins on the constitutional issue, she may turn around and sue Mason County for damages.

It was my original understanding that this all came to light while the David Carroll trial was still ongoing and that Estill had said he would not do anything to interfere. Which I took he would not do anything until that was all over. Just the way I took it. Second, OHIO gave her immunity not Maysville. I thought I read somewhere that Maysville was going to offer Carroll a deal to testify against her and then her testimony wouldn't have to be entered into evidence. I'm not sure either if David Carroll made the same statement in his trial that they desposed of the body in Maysville, if so then that could be used against her and maybe Maysville won't use her testimony making her
5th ammendment thing into play. It will all get very interesting before it is over I know that.

[DecupldSolutions]

You are very narrow minded, or maybe just sheltered.. Misinformed maybe? But definitely wrong..

Narrow minded. No. Ignorant, yes. Most assuredly not sheltered. Misinformed on occasion. But which point do you refer to? The one about the drugs or the MPD and extradition? Feel free to enligten me so I might expand my mind. I am interested in improvement.

...we will still (be) footing the bill for her in the form of welfare, food stamps, section 8 housing, heat assistance, etc., because she will probably never get a job because no one will hire her. So, at least in prison, she will not be living off the taxpayers AND have the privilage of being free to do whatever she wants to do every day. So there's the justice, imo.

She is not a Ky resident. OH residents foot that bill for her welfare. She can work. Freedom is an illusion. So Flame, your point is valid but for residents of this state. Federally, I guess there is a point. So we need to instill a work ethic in all of us. Because there are plenty of lazy people right here in town.

The rest of you may decry a lack of education on this users part. That is a flaw. Just stating an alternate viewpoint. But go ahead and hammer away. Call people from Ohio idiots and feel high and mighty that your collective impression of justice will be served. And the nail gets hammered...

It's bananas....

B A N A N A N A N.... monkey dance.

There is a precedent occuring. I hope this county does not get sued.

[cincydude1981]

I want to thank John Estill for wanting to take trash from Ohio and move it to Maysville. Actually I will speak on behalf of all Ohio residents and say thanks.
Did anyone from this town listen to Bill Cuningham show the other day. They blasted Maysville, Cincinnati pros. Deters made fun you Maysville stating the last big news to come out of Maysville was that a cow fell into a water well. I thought that was funny.
Moving on.................

[TheMan]

"Haha... what did the MPD have to do with Carroll extradition, charges filed? It would seem to be the work of Estill/Hendrickson. And what does that have to do with drugs from Cincy? Out of towners don't bring drugs to distribute. Locals go get them. Or have them shipped."

When you say things as truth that are not, it says one of a few things about you. I mentioned those things in a previous post.

What does MPD have to do with the extradition? While Mr. Estill is an excellent attorney, he doesn't have the manpower to investigate a crime. He relies on MPD and MCSO to do that for him. MPD detectives spent up wards to a month investigating this crime. They presented their findings to Estill and with that information he files the charges. And that's not taking anything away from the importance of his role.

And your misinformed as to the drug traffic in our city. To think that it's only brought in by locals is laughable.

While I agree that this prosecution is a form of vigilantly justice that our county should stay out of, your opinions expressed here as truth needed to be addressed.

[Flame]

I want to thank John Estill for wanting to take trash from Ohio and move it to Maysville. Actually I will speak on behalf of all Ohio residents and say thanks.
Did anyone from this town listen to Bill Cuningham show the other day. They blasted Maysville, Cincinnati pros. Deters made fun you Maysville stating the last big news to come out of Maysville was that a cow fell into a water well. I thought that was funny.
Moving on.................

I for one will take the last big story being a cow falling into a well. That would mean we have a pretty calm and nice place to live. Unlike Mr. Deter's area where there is two to three murders a day. In my opinion he has plenty he needs to focus on without worrying about what is going on here. He let someone that is so deep into a murder of a little child go free and Mr. Estill is trying to see she pays some small price for it. Mr. Deters needs to worry about his other murder cases(and there are many) and try to make sure ALL involved in those murders pay for their crimes then he won't have to worry about KY cleaning up his trash.

[DecupldSolutions]

When you say things as truth that are not, it says one of a few things about you. I mentioned those things in a previous post.

What does MPD have to do with the extradition? While Mr. Estill is an excellent attorney, he doesn't have the manpower to investigate a crime. He relies on MPD and MCSO to do that for him. MPD detectives spent up wards to a month investigating this crime. They presented their findings to Estill and with that information he files the charges. And that's not taking anything away from the importance of his role.

And your misinformed as to the drug traffic in our city. To think that it's only brought in by locals is laughable.

While I agree that this prosecution is a form of vigilantly justice that our county should stay out of, your opinions expressed here as truth needed to be addressed.

It is very likely that the majority of users here and just about anywhere have spoken a false truth at one time or another. We all tend to "shoot from the hip" on occasion. One of those things that this mistake might say about me is that I'm fallable just like the rest. What are the other things it tells you, sir?

I stand corrected. Had not read the other post. Thanks for the brief summary of the details. That was the desired answer. As far as the drug statement, mine was in response to the previous. Both situations occur. The statement should have been, "it isn't only out of towners that bring controlled substances for profit or otherwise." It is, as you said, laughable to think out of towners don't do so.

The nice thing about Maysville is that the worst thing to happen was a cow fell in the well. That is good. This is a relatively safe location. We have only come close to one murder or two this year. And that does put it ahead of say Cincy. Would rather live here than Cincy.

So, we are going to prosecute a person for telling the truth in agreement to a contract of sorts, when if the truth hadn't been told, no one would have known what really happened.
:Banane43: :Banane44: :Banane44: :Banane43:
Society will lay burden on this person for those actions well enough before this county needs to test a precedent.

Sorry. Just one of those things that fires it up. So I have to say, banana. What is to happen the next time we need to determine the truth and the one person that knows has to fear a double jeopardy of sorts? Maybe they will think of Mason county and clam up and the truth can not be determined. But the wheels are already turning. And so, I better get my dollars worth. I'm already going to have to pay an insane rate increase on water.

Oh and TheMan, you can use the quote icon to generate the quote script or type as follows:

[ Quote=TheMan ] copy and paste text to quote [ /Quote ]

Without the space after and before the brackets and get this nice box and all that in order to preserve the original text:

copy and paste text to quote

You probably knew that already. But it's something to exchange for the detail.

[TheMan]

It is very likely that the majority of users here and just about anywhere have spoken a false truth at one time or another. We all tend to "shoot from the hip" on occasion. One of those things that this mistake might say about me is that I'm fallable just like the rest. What are the other things it tells you, sir?

I stand corrected. Had not read the other post. Thanks for the brief summary of the details. That was the desired answer. As far as the drug statement, mine was in response to the previous. Both situations occur. The statement should have been, "it isn't only out of towners that bring controlled substances for profit or otherwise." It is, as you said, laughable to think out of towners don't do so.

The nice thing about Maysville is that the worst thing to happen was a cow fell in the well. That is good. This is a relatively safe location. We have only come close to one murder or two this year. And that does put it ahead of say Cincy. Would rather live here than Cincy.

So, we are going to prosecute a person for telling the truth in agreement to a contract of sorts, when if the truth hadn't been told, no one would have known what really happened.
:Banane43: :Banane44: :Banane44: :Banane43:
Society will lay burden on this person for those actions well enough before this county needs to test a precedent.

Sorry. Just one of those things that fires it up. So I have to say, banana. What is to happen the next time we need to determine the truth and the one person that knows has to fear a double jeopardy of sorts? Maybe they will think of Mason county and clam up and the truth can not be determined. But the wheels are already turning. And so, I better get my dollars worth. I'm already going to have to pay an insane rate increase on water.

Oh and TheMan, you can use the quote icon to generate the quote script or type as follows:

[ Quote=TheMan ] copy and paste text to quote [ /Quote ]

Without the space after and before the brackets and get this nice box and all that in order to preserve the original text:



You probably knew that already. But it's something to exchange for the detail.

I am perfectly aware of how this site works and how to quote. I believe doing so makes the posts messy and "choose" not to do so.

[Amandaann]

Okay I was trying to stay out of it but, I can't. has anyone thought that if Maysville did not try to do anything then that would show peeps that they could come here and commit crimes. Definatly get away with it.
How wrong is that.
I will pay extra taxes just to see her in jail. She deserves what ever she gets.
If not for disposing of the body but for keeping quiet so long. If she would have went to the police and said what she knew they would have protected her. It is her fault she is in this mess. Making her pay a little is better than nothing.

Court dates are, but if they tell you when they're leaving point A for point B, that's a security problem. I don't know, maybe they do that. I wouldn't.

Jeremy, If you listen to the police scannner, you hear about them transporting inmate from here to federal court or wherever they are scheduled. They will not announce the name of the rider but you could speculate. I agree with the security problem, I sure there are many people who would like to harm her(putting it nicely as posible) Police will do what they can to protect her.

By the way My brother is in jail they not only have cable but he says (if you can believe him) they have game systems If I recall the info right. I know that they have computers too, he types out some letters for the family.
HMMMMM jail sounds almost as good as the real world(work, 3.00 for gas, rent,) yeah jail better than real world. Just kidding, however it gives you meals a place to sleep It is better tha living on the streets.

[Amandaann]

DecupldSolutions

:Banane43: :Banane44: :Banane44: :Banane43:

Not a personal attack but this makes me want to skip any thing you say. It gives me a headache to try to read anything around it.

[jlmer]

I feel sorry for u Decupldsolutions, I can see u now in heaven standing in front of little Marcus, hey dude what up, yes they did find the ones that did that to u, they put two in jail for a long time, the other woman they set free, but my hometown try to put her away, but I was not going to let that happen, I had things I wanted to do with my money I wasn't letting them take my tax money for u. Anyway your not right anyway, nobody wanted u, so hey dude your better off, Decupldsolutions, I live from paycheck to paycheck and sometime still come up a day short, but I would pay all it take to put this woman away for as long as we can. I didn't know little Marcus, but I wished I had, I would love to have spent one day with him and show him what love and family all about. Its not all about money, life not all about money, I spend all the time I can with my childrens and grandchildrens, because u never know when some ............. woman like her will take them away. Iam going now because your statment has really upset me, to think people really think the way u do,,,,, money first, A child life later .;; Iam done

[DecupldSolutions]

Amandaann, no problem. Guess we won't be going out on a date any time soon.

TheMan, apologies ociffer. I have the opposite opinion on the quote box. No problem.

Jlmer, it's just not that simple. Please do not be upset. This is the internet. It's not worth it. Your hard work is admirable.

A childs life is our most precious resource. Little Marcus should not have left in such a manner.

The fact is, the crime was prosectuted in Ohio. This covers the incident that ocurred on the bridge also. If Mason Co. wanted to try the whole case from the beginning, I would support it. The case was handled in Ohio and is final. Fact is, a blurry line is being crossed where lots of money is going to be spent on a mere 5 year sentence to prosecute a protected witness who told the truth and another man who is serving a life sentece. So a precedent is being pushed, at taxpayer expense and a person serving a long time already; is going to undergo additional charges on the Mason Co. bill when those funds could be applied to the deserving people of Mason Co. or the existing court load. It is inappropriate.

This is an opinion. With some amount of logic. You are free to disagree.

[TheMan]

It wasn't the root of your logic that I disagreed with. It was your uniformed opinions that I did.

[Chuck]

I want to thank John Estill for wanting to take trash from Ohio and move it to Maysville. Actually I will speak on behalf of all Ohio residents and say thanks.
Did anyone from this town listen to Bill Cuningham show the other day. They blasted Maysville, Cincinnati pros. Deters made fun you Maysville stating the last big news to come out of Maysville was that a cow fell into a water well. I thought that was funny.
Moving on.................

I am very familiar with Deters and comments made by other prosecutors in Ohio related to this case and I am not surprised by them. I am against charges being filed in my home town against Baker but when I hear Deters is upset it makes it worth my hard earned tax dollars.

The fact he choose to go public with his little minded comments only reinforces my personal thoughts and opinion that the man is a self-centered, self-serving hypocrite.

After spending 18 years as a Peace Officer in Ohio I have seen things from the prosecution side that made my stomach turn. I have seen some of the best judges in Ohio that make up for it.

Mr. Estill, Ms. Hendrickson and the Maysville PD are of the finest quality and character in our State if not the Country. These personal slanderous attacks against them for doing their job as they are elected is unfounded and uncalled for.

Sorry but it just grinds me to no end when elected officials become so self-righteous that they must condemn others to justify their actions.

[mark]

So a precedent is being pushed, at taxpayer expense and a person serving a long time already; is going to undergo additional charges on the Mason Co. bill when those funds could be applied to the deserving people of Mason Co. or the existing court load. It is inappropriate.


............Hmm, I agree with you.

I've stated so elsewhere on this website & got pretty beat up for saying so.
The money spent here should be used to prosecute our own criminals................see ya mark

[jlmer]

A man and woman kills six childrens in Maysville Ky. , They go to Cincinnati Ohio and killed two , Cincinnti tried one and the other is set free for telling the truth, We the citizens of Mason co. are to set back and say well Cincinnati got them, we wont have to spend our tax money on them........ We need our money to go for the citizens of Mason Co. BULL----

[Jeremy]

I haven't really been following this, but I noticed a lot of the talk seems to be about the money spent prosecuting. Law should never be about the money. If it ever becomes about the money, the system is broke.

If it costs, say, $10,000 to prosecute someone and it gets around to reasoning that the person's crime wasn't worth $10,000, the system is broke.

If anything, large sums of money should be spent to ensure it isn't about the money. A great deal of money is spent in the law system, what's a few bucks defending the law system as not broke?

Plus, millions of dollars flow through this area all the time. Crazy money is spent in construction, maintenance, people's paychecks, and so on. If the town can't afford to pay something like $10,000 to prove a point, the town's got bigger problems than this.

I'm not a wasteful person by nature, but I think the idea of law is something worth investing in. Practically speaking, the person's crime might not be worth $10,000, but considering the amount of money spent in crime deterence, and how high-profile the case is, that's money invested, not wasted. Heck, the city might get that back in exposure of our humble town in outside media -- tourism, hotel taxes, and so on :) A lot of money is spent promoting a town. Two birds with one stone and all that.

$10,000 to prosecute is just a made up number. But if real, and considering there's roughly that in population, it's just a buck a person to preserve the appearance of justice. That's worth a buck I guess.

[Amandaann]

Amandaann, no problem. Guess we won't be going out on a date any time soon.



I never said anything about a date, But if you are asking sorry I have already found the love of my life. Seven years with him HMMM I think I will stay. I'm in for the long haul. lol